Sunday, 30 April 2017

Editorials 


The AFSPA plea

One cannot simply comprehend the necessity of the draconian Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) or its special powers among the civil population. The central government has recently approached the Supreme Court for review of 2016 decision to do away with the impunity extended to members of armed forces under the AFSPA. It had indeed given a fresh impetus to the human rights movement in the northeast region. While the judgment had been hailed in many quarters, top generals and retired army officers are raising hue and cry over it. They argue that it will be very difficult to operate in ‘disturbed areas’ if the special powers to armed forces are diluted and that tougher laws are needed to contain terrorism. Experts have opined that tougher laws are not the answer to the problem, as is evident from the effects of prolonged imposition of AFSPA in the state, but rather the problem lies with the army, the implementing agency. Laws that grant room for abuse or misuse of its provisions to the implementing agencies are the real culprits hiding behind the façade of curbing terrorism. Lessons can be learnt from instances around the world where draconian laws which allow the security forces to keep in detention indefinitely or even shoot down any person at will has, far from bringing down terrorism in Iraq, have only led to conditions which have created more terrorists who are blowing themselves up and hundreds of people every day. Leaving aside punitive laws, we even have preventive laws in the form of the National Security Act, 1980 and Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act as ways and means to curb terrorism and unlawful activities. The National Security Act has been solely enacted for the purpose of maintaining public order and security of the state. However, we have seen a number of individuals being arbitrarily detained under the Act in the state in unprecedented proportions, even in cases which do not affect the maintenance of public order and security of the state, from which we may pertinently arrive at the conclusion that it is one of the instances of gross abuse of the provisions of the law by the implementing agencies. Ordinary laws are far more adequate to deal with the present law and order situation without taking recourse to extraordinary laws which only serves to further aggravate the ongoing crisis. The problem with AFSPA is that it not only facilitates humans rights violations by the members of armed forces, but it also creates an imagined culture of impunity among the other forces including the state police and paramilitary forces who are not vested with special powers. The 2016 verdict of the apex court had made it clear that there is no ‘warlike’ situation in Manipur but ‘internal disturbance’ and that a person merely carrying arms in a disturbed area does not become an enemy. The court also noted that killing an ‘enemy’ was not the only available solution and stressed that this is what the Geneva Conventions and the principles of international humanitarian law say. There is simply no ambiguity in the verdict. The central government’s recent plea to Supreme Court for a review of the 2016 verdict needs to be analysed and dissected. It feels, the immunity enjoyed by armed forces in areas under AFSPA would be diluted and the floodgates would be opened for other violations as well besides fake encounters. This would be a calamity for the armed forces operating in conflict ridden states, as they feel. Human rights organizations need to counter the plea in earnest.

Leader Writer: Irengbam Arun

14-Apr-2017 / IFP Editorials / 0 Comments

Comments


No comments found for this entry!


Random Items 

NSUI alleges mistakes in text book

IMPHAL | Apr 29 National Students Union of India (NSUI) has sought attention of Education Minister Th Radheshyam to the “wrong interpretation” of Manipur history in the CBSE class five text book titled “Mind Xpress” on page 32. In a press meet held at t.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

MSF cries foul

IMPHAL | Apr 29 Manipur Students’ Federation (MSF) has demanded the state government and Education minister to investigate the unlawful recruitment of 38 posts including one under secretary of the Council of Higher Secondary Education, COSHEM without fol.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Biswajit urges MSME ministry for more projects

IMPHAL | Apr 29 Minister of Textiles, Commerce and Industries, Th Biswajit Singh drew the attention of the Union Minister of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Kalraj Mishra for taking up more projects under the ministry in Manipur to solve unemploymen.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Push for better drainage system

IMPHAL | Apr 29 “Nahakhong Maril Shengba” an initiative to clean Nahakhong Maril of Uripok Wards No. four and five was inaugurated today by Deputy Chief Minister Yumnam Joykumar at the community hall of Uripok Sorbon Thingel in Imphal West. The initiati.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Police seize liquor at Moirang area

IMPHAL | April 29 A combined team of Moirang police station personnel and commando team of Bishnupur under instruction of the SDPO Moirang raided several hotels at Moirang area today. The team seized assorted qualities of Indian Made Foreign Liquor and.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

AITUC to observe May Day

IMPHAL | Apr 29 The All India Trade Union Congress, Manipur will be observing the 127th May Day Celebration on May 1, from 1:00 pm at GM Hall Imphal. A release said the observation will be attended by E Tombi Singh, deputy Labour commissioner, governmen.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Look Good on the Go-Essential Summer travel tips from beauty diva Shahnaz Husain for Cool Journey

By Ms Shahnaz Husain Time flies when you're having fun with kids , friends and family members on hills and beaches during summer holiday, right? The summer vacations are just around the corner and you must be planning holidays in cool atmosphere in beac.....

30-Apr-2017 | IFP Articles | 0 Comments

IFC minister inspects Pumlenpat

IMPHAL | Apr 29 IFCD minister Letpao Haokip along with MLA of Hiyanglam AC Dr Radheshyam Yumnam today inspected Pumlenpat and Khoidumpat to assess feasibility of constructing water channel there. According to a release Radheshyam said that vast tract .....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

State observes world veterinary day

IMPHAL | Apr 29 As observed in India and around the globe, the state also observed `The World Veterinary Day- 2017` on the theme,``Antimicrobial Registance- From Awareness to Action`` at the auditorium of Lamyanba Shanglen, Palace Gate, here today. The o.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

People’s participation needed in governance: Letpao

IMPHAL | Apr 29 “Every action of the government is your business and every single penny spent by the government is your money. The government belongs to the people,” IFCD and YAS minister Letpao Haokip said and urged the people not to hesitate to take th.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Trinamool refutes merger claim

IMPHAL | Apr 29 Remaining office bearers of Manipur Pradesh Trinamool Congress today refuted the claim by the BJP that the state unit of the Trinamool Congress was merged with BJP. The party office bearers clarified that there is no such act of merger by.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Hindi as compulsory national language is unfair to most Indians

By Garga Chatterjee Imagine you are a citizen of the Indian Union. Imagine you are a non-Hindi speaker who does not know Hindi and imagine your friend is a Hindi speaker who does not know your non-Hindi mother language. You two are co-citizens of a repub.....

30-Apr-2017 | IFP Articles | 0 Comments

Latest Comments