Sunday, 30 April 2017

Editorials 


Chain reactions

The spiral of numerous ethnic insurrections in Manipur, often with one literally dove-tailing the other is evidence to the complicated nature of the issue in hand. It is not too rare to read reports by journalists and commentators from outside the state telling the story with patronising bewilderment that Manipur is witness to 30 and odd different insurgencies at one time. The number 30 is never accurately spelled out, giving the impression that they have lost count, and that these dime-a-dozen insurgencies have very little significance left. Often these stories also imply, in the same tone of condescension, that these insurgencies are floated as if they were cottage industries by people who want a little quick buck. A lot of these perceptions are understandable and even may hold some water, but when they are presented as the total picture, it betrays either intellectual dishonesty, or more probably, an abject failure to grasp the picture in its entirety. The broad brush, any painter will testify, is a tool often used to shroud and mystify a subject so as to disguise and give credence to ignorance of the inner dynamics of the subject.

And so, in the portrayal of insurgency in not just Manipur but the entire Northeast region, the popular resort has been to rely on images of primitive clannish tribal loyalties, mutual and irreconcilable atavistic hostilities amongst tribal groups, primordial xenophobia reminiscent of the days of savagery, etc. This approach leaves little room for a resolution apart from keeping the warring parties separated from each other (just as the instinctually determined hostility between cats and dogs is resolved by keeping them apart). This approach is quite unlike in the case of other deadly conflicts, such as was seen in Punjab. In these situations, the same analysts would forward economic and political causes and consequently profoundly actionable economic and political solutions. One is reminded of the outburst of one of literature’s most famous characters, Shylock: “If you prick us do we not bleed.” The Jewish blood and the Christian blood are both red, so why different standards in assessing them.

But if the portrayal of the phenomenon of the multiplication of ethnic insurrections as wild assertions of primeval loyalties is to be treated as only a smokescreen to hide abject inability to comprehend the deeper currents, what then are the real issues? What then has led to this phenomenal proliferation of ethnic insurgencies? Observing just the last decade of the multi-pronged conflicts in Manipur should provide some clues. A prominent historical landmark in this regard would be the Naga-Kuki feud in the early 1990s. Before this cataclysmic development, militancy amongst the Kukis was barely heard of. It was only after this period that Kuki militant groups began spawning, and the existing ones began reorganising themselves into much more potent fighting forces than they previously were. But the culprit, rather than the supposed instinctual animosity that so many have, and still rely on, always was in our opinion, aggressive sectarian nationalism against the backdrop of a weak administration, morally de-legitimised by corruption and inefficiency.

Such brands of nationalisms, always manage to alienate those either excluded or else in the margin of it, and the state institution being virtually absent, these marginal groups have nowhere else to look for security or succour than to raise their own militias. And there is no gainsaying that the early 1990s were the heydays of overbearing Naga nationalism with the NSCN(IM) emerging as the predominant Naga insurgent group, pushing the agenda of Nagalim (Greater Nagaland) with unprecedented aggression. But if aggressive Naga nationalism led to the consolidation of militant Kuki nationalism, this in turn made other communities at its fringe insecure. The confounding feud between kindred tribes, the Kukis and the Paites almost in the immediate wake of the Kuki-Naga feuds, may be thus explained. The truce document ultimately signed between these latter tribes spelled out these underlying causes pretty succinctly. The spiral however does not end here. There are also other parallel spirals. As for instance, aggressive Meitei nationalism is also having similar responses. Hence, even the origin of militancy amongst the Meitei-Pangals may be explained within this frame. The vehemence with the Meitei Mayek was opposed in the hill districts etc, may also be part of this same phenomenon. Plenty of lessons here, but who is willing to learn, is the big question.

5-Apr-2017 / IFP Editorials / 0 Comments

Comments


No comments found for this entry!


Random Items 

Police seize liquor at Moirang area

IMPHAL | April 29 A combined team of Moirang police station personnel and commando team of Bishnupur under instruction of the SDPO Moirang raided several hotels at Moirang area today. The team seized assorted qualities of Indian Made Foreign Liquor and.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

NSUI alleges mistakes in text book

IMPHAL | Apr 29 National Students Union of India (NSUI) has sought attention of Education Minister Th Radheshyam to the “wrong interpretation” of Manipur history in the CBSE class five text book titled “Mind Xpress” on page 32. In a press meet held at t.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Promote tourism for better human relationship, says Dr Ranjan

UKHRUL | Apr 29 Consultative meeting for the successful conduct of Shirui Lily Festival was held at DRDA Hall, Ukhrul today. The consultative meeting was attended by Dr Sapam Rajan, parliamentary secretary Tourism, MLAs from Ukhrul district, ADC members.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

JAC condemns

IMPHAL | Apr 29 The Joint Action Committee (JAC) for Mapithel Dam Downstream Affected People (MDDAP), Imphal East has strongly condemned for not inviting its representatives in the delegation held to address the grievances of the Mapithel dam-affected vi.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Push for better drainage system

IMPHAL | Apr 29 “Nahakhong Maril Shengba” an initiative to clean Nahakhong Maril of Uripok Wards No. four and five was inaugurated today by Deputy Chief Minister Yumnam Joykumar at the community hall of Uripok Sorbon Thingel in Imphal West. The initiati.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Biswajit urges MSME ministry for more projects

IMPHAL | Apr 29 Minister of Textiles, Commerce and Industries, Th Biswajit Singh drew the attention of the Union Minister of Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Kalraj Mishra for taking up more projects under the ministry in Manipur to solve unemploymen.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Man with drugs nabbed

IMPHAL | Apr 29 As a part of drive against drugs, Imphal east district police team comprising of Narcotic cell, Imphal East along with women police led by Inspector N John under the supervision of SDPO, Porompat, Roni Mayengbam conducted raids in three l.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

People’s participation needed in governance: Letpao

IMPHAL | Apr 29 “Every action of the government is your business and every single penny spent by the government is your money. The government belongs to the people,” IFCD and YAS minister Letpao Haokip said and urged the people not to hesitate to take th.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Trinamool refutes merger claim

IMPHAL | Apr 29 Remaining office bearers of Manipur Pradesh Trinamool Congress today refuted the claim by the BJP that the state unit of the Trinamool Congress was merged with BJP. The party office bearers clarified that there is no such act of merger by.....

30-Apr-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Statue of Raja Goukhothang unveiled

CHURACHANDPUR | Apr 29 The statue of the only chief among the descendent of Zo or Zo Suan, (L) Raja Goukhothang was unveiled at G Tonjang village which lies at the suburbs of proper Lamka town today. The unveiling function was attended by people of diff.....

30-Apr-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

ZYF lauds govt plan to revive MST

IMPHAL | Apr 29 Lauding the state governemnt’s plan to re-introduce the Manipur State Transport (MST) and to revive the passenger services in order to facilitate the people from far areas and hill districts, the Zeliangrong Youth Front has urged sp.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

AITUC to observe May Day

IMPHAL | Apr 29 The All India Trade Union Congress, Manipur will be observing the 127th May Day Celebration on May 1, from 1:00 pm at GM Hall Imphal. A release said the observation will be attended by E Tombi Singh, deputy Labour commissioner, governmen.....

30-Apr-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Latest Comments