Tuesday, 21 February 2017


Ignored by district debates

In the myriad discussions on the controversy of the Manipur Government’s recent creation of seven new districts, there is one deafening silence among those slamming the government’s move as sinister and supposedly calculated to divide the Nagas for electoral gains. For whatever the reason, everybody seems to be taking it so much for granted that the parties involved in this unseemly drama are not just the United Naga Council and the Government of Manipur, and that there is at least one other very important and immediate stakeholder – the SADAR Hills District Demand Committee, which, it may be recalled had also resorted to similar coercive tactics as the UNC before and are equally capable of doing it again in the event of their demand being turned down. In fact, it will also be recalled that this committee had also called for a blockade after the UNC had called theirs on November 1 in anticipation of the state government giving in to the former’s demand. This second blockade was withdrawn within a few days, probably on the government’s assurance that their long standing demand would be met, and was indeed met as per the cabinet decision of December 8 midnight. Let everybody know it then, there cannot be any solution by any bilateral or trilateral agreement reached between the UNC, Government of Manipur and Government of India, if other stake holders continue to be so stubbornly ignored. Together with the demand for SADAR Hills district was also Jiribam on the Assam border. This tiny enclave of predominantly non-tribal population of Meiteis and Bengalis could not have been made a part of any district reserved for STs, such as Tamenglong, for the legal and administrative problems this would have caused in terms of land ownership and enfranchisement, to name just two foreseen hurdles. This enclave was all this while attached to the non-reserved Imphal East district, 220km away, and the logistics problems this would meant for domiciles of this former sub-division even in matters of acquiring simple but necessary official documents such as the Adhar card, is only to be imagined. The district status for Jiribam therefore is well reasoned. Tribal populations in non-reserved districts pose no problem for these populations can continue to be as they were wherever they are, but it is not so the other way around. There are many countries, such as Canada, where tribal populations who have settled in non-reserved provinces, and are engaged in modern professions, are deemed ceased to be tribal, and for these countries, maybe the opposite logic works, but this norm is not in practice in India.

Our basic contention is, if the SADAR Hills issue is to be put to rest, domiciles of SADAR Hills cannot be ignored in the discussions. Even if the claim that a big section of the population here are not original is to be given some credence for argument’s sake, the question remains as to what defines an “original population”. Can populations who have settled at any place for 200 years or more be still termed as aliens? It may be recalled even the effort by those demanding a restriction on immigrant influx into the state through a legislation similar to the Inner Line Permit System, to give this definition a legally tangible shape by taking the base year of settlement of “original populations” as 1951, was rejected by the President of India, and rightly so too. Our approach on this matter has always been “thus far but no more”, so that those who are already in the state should be treated as bona fide domiciles. However, we have also always argued there must be a way to ensure no further influx and land transfers to immigrants happen. A legislation to regulate and restrict further influx would be the most democratic way of doing this. It is true immigrants bring in new skills and knowledge, but it is equally true immigrants drastically pull down wages much to the detriment of the local labour and employment markets. Why just Manipur, even superpowers and super markets such as the US and EU are facing this problem, and because little precautions were taken in the past, the ugly backlash has been for bigoted leaders to come to power in these countries on immigrant demonising campaigns.

We also fail to see how the other districts which have been split caused any division of populations. In the non-Naga districts, there have been no problem and in fact the decision was celebrated with fanfare. In the Naga districts too, we cannot still figure out how any division has been caused. Ukhrul and Kamjong will both remain predominantly Tangkhul provinces as they always have been; Tamenglong and Nungba will also both be Zeliangrong provinces; and Chandel and Tengnoupal will retain their population mix as before. Moreover, these new district were separate Assembly constituencies already so how do these new districts amount to sinister divisions of populations?

3-Jan-2017 / IFP Editorials / 0 Comments


No comments found for this entry!

Random Items 

No Kangla meeting for BJP

IMPHAL | Feb 20 The proposed political convention of the BJP inside the premises of Kangla, which is to be addressed by the Prime Minister Narendra Modi this month, has been relocated to a different venue following complaint by PRJA to the election commi.....

21-Feb-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Top post for Hangkhanlian: Chaoba

CCDPUR | Feb 20 Top BJP leader Th Chaoba today campaigned hard for party candidate V Hangkhanlian of Churachandpur constituency giving a hint that he would be given a top post in the next government. Th Chaoba was speaking at the flag hoisting function o.....

21-Feb-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

4 withdraws nomination 

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Four candidates have withdrawn their candidatures on the last date of withdrawal for the first phase of the ensuing 11th state assembly election, to be held on March 8. The candidates are one each from Lilong, Wangjing Tentha, Jiribam a.....

21-Feb-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Congress pledges to safeguard territory

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Manipur PCC released today its election manifesto for the ensuing state assembly elections promising a constitutional safeguard for the territorial integrity of Manipur. The manifesto was released by CP Joshi, general secretary, AICC and .....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Free educational institutions: KNF

KANGPOKPI | Feb 20 The Education department of Kuki National Front (KNF) in its aim to boost education sector in the district today appeals all concerned to make educational institutions of Kangpokpi district a free and peaceful zone. A release stated t.....

21-Feb-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

ZUF threatening Congress

IMPHAL | Feb 20 BJP in nexus with armed group of Zeliangrong United Front (ZUF) are threatening Congress workers in the Khoupum sub division of Noney district, charged Manipur Pradesh Congress Committee (MPCC) spokesperson Khumukcham Joykishan Singh. Jo.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Framework agreement would not affect state: Biren

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Former MLA Nongthombam Biren assured that the framework agreement would not adversely affect the state. Addressing at a flag hoisting ceremony for Bharitya Janata Party (BJP) candidate Yumkham Erabot Singh of Wangkhei assembly constituen.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

International eye care day on March 3

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Since the first International Conference on prevention and Rehabilitation of hearing impairment was held in Beijing, China on March 3rd 2007, the day is observed as ‘International Ear-care Day’ every year across the world. The day is obs.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Two days seminar at MU

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Two days seminar on North East India since 1947 under society, polity and economy with reference to the state of Manipur began today at Committee Room, Vice Chancellor’s Office, Manipur University, Canchipur, Imphal. The seminar was orga.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Rajnath’s promise not enough: AMSU

IMPHAL | Feb 20 The All Manipur Students Union reiterating its demand for detail of the ‘Framework Agreement’ signed between the government of India and the NSCN (IM) said no power in the world can underestimate Manipur. A release said without the cons.....

21-Feb-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

‘Jiribam peaceful under Debendra’

Jiri News Network JIRIBAM | Feb 20 Ahead of the 11th Manipur legislative assembly election, a flag hosting ceremony along with public meeting was held today at the residence of Thoudam Debendra Singh who is the candidate of Indian National Congress (IN.....

21-Feb-2017 | Agency | 0 Comments

Shrinking aspirations

It is alarming to note the manner in which aspirations in Manipur by and large have been systematically shrinking in size and scope. Today, it is as if young people see no other handle to success in life than securing a government job – any government job.....

21-Feb-2017 | IFP Editorials | 0 Comments

Latest Comments