Wednesday, 18 January 2017


MPSC’s Latest RTI reply hints at massive irregularity in 2010 MCS exam

Respected Sir,

Most of the examinations conducted by the MPSC do not happily get finished without a controversy. Be it for a right reason or wrong reason. We do find instances where many candidates who felt Set down use to take legal recourse for redressal of their grievances. I am also one of such candidates who have fought retentfessly to get to the bottom of the alleged violation of the MCSCC Examination Rules in the conduct of 2010 MCS/MPS exam. My whole fight actually began when I was informed by the MPSC vide RTI reply dated 05-11-2012 that I had not obtained the qualifying mark in the General English paper and as such my other seven main papers had not been evaluated by virtue of the provision incorporated under Note (ii) of Section II of Chapter It of the aforesaid Rules. Surprisingly, it was later found that all my seven main papers had been duly evaluated by the concerned examiners which virtually put me in the fourth position of the overall written test of the said exam. Leaving aside all these for a while, what concerns us the most at the moment is how MPSC had applied the same provisions of Note (ii) in 2010 exam and subsequently in 2013 & 2014 exams. To get a complete picture of 2010 exam, we need to move a little back to the court proceeding. During the writ proceedings, MPSC by filing an affidavit had submitted that that the provision under Note (ii) is only a directory rule, but not a mandatory rule that until and unless the qualifying paper (General English Paper) is examined and the result thereof is out, the other papers cannot be examined. MPSC further submitted that there is no such legal necessity that the General English paper should be examined first and therefore, under compelling circumstances, all the papers of the candidates including General English paper were examined at the same time (simultaneously) to save time, money and everything. Thus the initial statement made by the MPSC in their RTI reply which indicated non-evaluation of my seven papers on account of my failure to obtain the qualifying mark in General English paper and the later statement made by the MPSC in their affidavit regarding simultaneous evaluation of all the papers including General English paper are contradictory to one another. Even though the Hon'ble High Court of Manipur has also decided the case in my favour, the controversy surrounding 2010 exam does not seem to end even today. The recent development has further put a serious question mark on the credibility of those officers of the MPSC who were at the helm of affairs during 2010 exam, I had filed another RTI application on 01-10-2014 but this time with respect to 2013 and 2014 examinations. The information which I sought were how many candidates have failed to qualify in the General English paper in 2013 and 2014 exams and whether the remaining seven main papers of those candidates who had failed to qualify in the Genera! English paper have been evaluated further or not. Despite my repeated request, MPSC refused to furnish the information. Then I had filed a complaint petition before the Central information Commission (CIC). On the direction of the CIC, Manipur Information Commission took up the matter and summoned some officials of the MPSC. Consequent to that, the information has been finally provided by the MPSC after almost eight months vide RTI reply dated 12-06-2015 which reveals that only 7 candidates in 2013 Exam and 14 candidates in 2014 Exam had not qualified in the General English paper and the other seven main papers of the said candidates had not been evaluated, (in 2010 exam, 109 candidates were deliberately disqualified in General English paper).Therefore, the subsequent action of the MPSC clearly implies that 2013 and 2014 exams had been conducted with maximum care keeping in mind the legal requirement as envisaged under Note (ii) of the examination Rules.The word 'directory' as cleverly invented by the MPSC in order to sweep the irregularities of 2010 exam under the carpet had ultimately become a 'mandatory' one in the subsequent examinations.Summing up, the latest RTI reply which has vividly reflected MPSC's strict adherence to the examination Rules in 2013 and 2014 exams regarding evaluation of seven main papers of only those candidates who had qualified in General English paper almost confirms that MPSC had altogether violated the provisions of note (ii) in 2010 exam. This again leads to the logical conclusion that the MPSC had also made a conscious attempt to interfere with the due judicial process by misinterpreting the provision of note (ii) as a "directory" rule. Lastly, MPSC may win or lose court cases but somebody has to be necessarily there to take cognizance of serious acts of impropriety or immorality committed by any of its officials. Always switching to the idea of fighting every case in a court of law by hook or by crook is not a healthy proposition for a constitutional authority like MPSC. Legal expense is not a big deal for MPSC so long as they are getting adequate fund from the State government. But for an individual litigant, it is an uphill task to fight a case financially.Transparency and accountability is what everybody expects from MPSC but not 'manipulation' 'discrimination1 and 'litigation'. The deadly combination of this trio can ruin the entire lives of many deserving candidates.

Yours Faithfully
Hanjabam Bobby Sharma
S/o H. Kunjakishor Sharma
BrahmapurThangapat Mapal, Imphal East

8-Jul-2015 / IFP Letters / 0 Comments


No comments found for this entry!

Random Items 

Tousem students boycott ex-MLA Kikhonbou

IMPHAL| Jan 17 A group of Tousem based student bodies have boycotted ex-MLA of Tamei Z Kikhonbou Newmai who recently resigned from both Congress and the Manipur legislative assembly. A joint statement of Tousem HQ Student Union, All Zeme Students’ Union.....

18-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Election punditry

Just two and a half months away from the March elections to the Manipur Legislative Assembly, pundits are busy interpreting how the sorry state of affairs prevailing in Manipur at the moment following the UNC indefinite blockade along Manipur’s two lifeli.....

18-Jan-2017 | IFP Editorials | 0 Comments

ATDUM condemns loot

IMPHAL | Jan 17 All Tribal Disables’ Union Manipur (ATDUM) has strongly condemned the physical assault, loot and inhuman treatment committed by unidentified goons claiming to be underground cadres towards the District Social Welfare Officers (DSWOs) of d.....

18-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

NSCN(IM) seeks ZD Bon release

IMPHAL | Jan 17 The NSCN(IM) has asked security forces to adhere to the agreed ceasefire ground rules and unconditionally release of senior leader ZD Bon, Steering executive member at Bhalok/Phalong junction by the 14 Sikh Regiment under Tamei Batallion .....

18-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Discussion on understanding conflict

IMPHAL | Jan 17 The discussion on ‘Understanding the conflict of Manipur’ jointly organised by North East Dialogue Forum, Social Youth Development and Youth’s Forum for Protestation was held today at Kakching Khunou community hall. The discussion was he.....

18-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

No structural defect, says MDS

IMPHAL | Jan 17 Manipur Development Society (MDS) authorities today denied structural damage to the secured office building located at AT Lines, Imphal. There was widespread panic among employees in the ‘secure’ office building as cracks began to appear.....

18-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Gaidon, Stephen remanded     to further police custody

IMPHAL | Jan 17 The United Naga Council (UNC) president, Gaidon Kamei and publicity and information secretary, Shangkhil Stephen were remanded to police custody for five more days by Chief Judicial Magistrate, Imphal East, A Noutuneshori Devi. They were.....

18-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Rs 50 cr in old notes deposited in UBI Tamenglong

By Daniel Kamei TAMENGLONG | Jan 17 After demonetization of Rs. 1000 and Rs. 500 notes in India people of Tamenglong has deposited more than Rs. 50 crores in the lone United Bank of India Tamenglong Branch. Revealing this to IFP, manager of UBI Tamenglo.....

18-Jan-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

Festive time in new Pherzawl district

CHURACHANDPUR | Jan 17 It is a festive season in Pherzawl, the newly inaugurated headquarters of the largest district of the state bifurcated from the erstwhile Churachandpur district. Yesterday, the district headquarters was swamped by local leaders an.....

18-Jan-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

CHQ told to take specific steps

IMPHAL | Jan 17 High Court of Manipur has directed government authorities to convene immediately a meeting of combined headquarters (CHQ), which is chaired by the chief minister O Ibobi Singh to take decisions to get the blockade lifted. A full bench of.....

18-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Trinamool ticket

IMPHAL| Jan 17 The Manipur Pradesh Trinamool Congress Committee has issued notification inviting intending candidates who are willing to contest the 11th state assembly election 2017 on Trinamool Congress Party ticket. The notification said, application.....

18-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Assembly elections of 2017 : an overview

By Thoudam Imomacha Singh As the Election Commission of India (ECI) has proclaimed the commencement of Assembly Elections in Manipur and other four State of Goa, Punjab, Uttarakhand and Uttar Pradesh, the stage is set for electioneering in these parts of.....

18-Jan-2017 | IFP Articles | 0 Comments

Latest Comments