Monday, 23 January 2017


I Am A Manipuri, So I Am A Liar: Globally speaking

By Amar Yumnam

Manipuris are now emerging or rather have been made to emerge as a bunch of liars. Anybody who connects with the rest of the world while still staying on the soil of Manipur is necessarily made to look like a liar in the rest of the world. Modern world and her contemporary development stand on trustworthy flows of information, communication and ideas. These flows necessarily demand honouring the deadline and timely response to communication. But these are impossible things to perform while still being a home-stuck son or daughter of the soil of Manipur. Further, information technology is a fundamental medium of communication across countries in the world today. Whenever anyone send a communication from any corner of the world to another corner, it is necessarily and generally expected that a reply should be elicited within twenty-four hours. This is where we are now seen around the globe as the most unreliable and untrustworthy group of people who do not respect time and commitment to the deadline. There would be weeks and months when we would go without access to internet and without the luxury of power; unfortunately information technology does not work with candles. These would necessarily imply that we would remain without responding to any of the communications and respecting any of the deadlines committed to anywhere under the sun. When after days, weeks and months, we would respond to the various communications (because of the large time lag, we cannot even respond to all the communications at one go as the accumulated mail gets piled up) expressing regrets for the delay in responding. We would write that the period of delay was because of the failure of the internet connection and the power outages. Then there would be no further communication from the other end. At this period of the twenty-first century and belonging to one the most venerable emerging economies (India), nobody in this world now believes that we have problems of internet connection and power failures for elongated periods. It is only the miniscule few who had visited the land would realise that in Manipur these are real problems. The end-effect of all this is that the world now sees Manipur and her people undependable for long term connections and relationships; the people in this land care a hoot for the deadlines and continuous flow of communications.

The contemporary world values speed and efficiency. In fact, the relative competency over others are founded on these, individually, socially, nationally and internationally. There are some significant studies emerging of late which examine the ill-effects of cumulative exposure to disadvantages. Three important observations have emerged:
1.    “Growing up in a poverty concentration neighbourhood can have a long lasting negative effect on incomes of children as adults.
2.    Cumulative exposure to poverty concentration neighbourhoods leads to a lower income later in life.
3.    For those belonging to a non-Western ethnic minority there is an additional penalty for growing up in a poverty concentration neighbourhood.”

Now when we extend this analysis beyond individuals and to the land and people of Manipur, and particularly in the context of the Act East Policy, the world outside finds Guwahati and Shillong as more dependable points of communication and relationships than Imphal. One may say and take excuse in it that the insurgency prevalent in Manipur is the culprit. Here I would hasten to assert that it is not. The state of infrastructure and the character and the quality of governance are the spoilers. The significance of infrastructure as foundations of development and much beyond items of interest of the contractors and the contract-providers (read powers that be in government) have long been emphasised. An additional finding of latest research in development is the significance of writing as a strong correlate of development – “more statistically robust and significant relationship of writing with state emergence than with agricultural transition, supporting the notion of a special role of states in the adoption and transmission of writing systems”. We can extend this research into the failures of information technology and power by the government imposed on the people and the resultant exposure of the people of Manipur as habitual liars to the rest of the world as the same as the failure to evolve writing in the society. Or is it a case that the government of the day wishes all the people were illiterates and would not bother to write; this would have been a very convenient environment to rule for the powers that be. In one of the most significant articles of this year titled “Why human rights are called human rights”, Alan Sussman writes in the June 2014 issue of the journal of Ethics and International Affairs: “Historical memory—the memory of what we have done to each other—is a decidedly human attribute. It could be said that one may scarcely be human without it. It could also be said that without memory there could be no possibility of imagination, and without imagination, no moral imagination.” When the world sees that the Manipuris do not respond in time and do not respect deadlines, the historical memory advises the former to work more closely with the people in the North East other than the Manipuris. This situation has been made inevitably happen due to long failures in power and information technology; these are the areas where the state (read government) is expected to play the pivotal role in societies needing to move towards transformation for better well-being (societies requiring to move from ill-being to well-being).  Hussman also quotes the January 1941 State of the Union speech of Franklin D. Roosevelt where he propounded the celebrated  “Four Freedoms”: “We look forward to a world founded upon four essential human freedoms. The first is freedom of speech and expression everywhere in the world. The second is freedom of every person to worship God in his own way—everywhere in the world. The third is freedom from want . . . everywhere in the world. The fourth is freedom from fear . . . anywhere in the world.” Interpreting this contextually and contemporaneously, we may now ask if reliable access to the information technology and power are not human rights for ensuring movement from ill-being to well-being. In any case, the governance should not be indulging in the collectively damaging game of projecting the Manipuris as undependable and habitual liars to the rest of the world.

22-Dec-2014 / IFP Articles / 1 Comments



23-Dec-2014 | 12:11 PM

The writer has good intention in calling all the Manipuris liars. But then he has exaggerated the problem of Internet connectivity and power. if someone expects some communications from somebody he/she has all the resources to be glued to internet, even in Manipur even today. we have internet connections through mobile phones too. even a toddler knows how to operate. the issue may not be of connections but of priority. He/she may not feel like checking mail but may be glued to facebook 24/7. So only the lazy people have the fancy of calling themselves liars. at least not me Sir. And i am a Manipuri too.

Random Items 

Police clarifies

IMPHAL | Jan 22 The police department has clarified over the allegation carried in local daily stating that the Wangoi Police Station and Women Police Station, Imphal West refused to register a case regarding the abduction and rape of two minor girls at .....

23-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Digital photo contest to be held

IMPHAL | Jan 22 Images of Manipur will be organising the 1st Manipur Sangai International Digital Photo Contest (Salon) 2017 under the aegis of Federation of Indian Photography, Federation de Internationale of Photographique (FlAP) World Forum and Alanti.....

23-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Confusion in VDF

CCPUR | Jan 22 The Village Defence Force (VDF) personnel in Churachandpur are in a dilemma as to whether they will be drafted into election duty or not. Secretary of Manipur VDF Welfare Association S Laltingen Vaiphei said that they are confused with th.....

23-Jan-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

Resolving conflicts

The blockade along two national highways which serve as the lifelines of Manipur is now nearing the completion of three months. Yet there is no sign the problem is nearing a resolution. Of late there have been speculations of a tripartite summit between t.....

23-Jan-2017 | IFP Editorials | 0 Comments

Prize Distribution function at Thoubal Moijing

THOUBAL | Jan 22 A Meritorious Prize Distribution function was organised today by the managing committee of Thoubal Moijing High School, Thoubal to honour and encourage meritorious student of the school. The prize distribution function organised under t.....

23-Jan-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

BRT observes foundation day

IMPHAL | Jan 22 The Banian Repertory Theatre (BRT) observed its 33rd Foundation Day at its office complex today, said a release singned by the secretary of BRT L Tikendra Singh. It further said the observance function was attended by former BRT secretar.....

23-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Search operation

IMPHAL | Jan 22 A team of Imphal West police conducted a cordon and house to house search operation at Liwa road Oinam Leikai to flush out militants ahead of Republic Day celebration. During the operation which started at 5.20 am lasted till 6.40 am, th.....

23-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Nupi Marup demands 50 percent quota

IMPHAL | Jan 22 Representatives of All Manipur Nupi Marup (AMNM) met the Governor of Manipur Dr Najma Haptullah yesterday and submitted a memorandum demanding to implement 50 percent quota for women in the Municipalities and Panchayats in the state of .....

23-Jan-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Art contest held to educate voters

IMPHAL | Jan 22 Chief electoral officer’s office, in association with two other organisations held a painting competition in Imphal today to increase voter awareness as a part of the Systematic Voter Education and Electoral Participation (SVEEP) campaign.....

23-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

No doctors at Nungba CHC

By Daniel Kamei TAMENGLONG | Jan 22 Absence of doctors in the hill districts is not a new phenomenon. It is the same in the case of the Community Health Centre (CHC) at Nungba in Noney district. Although a few doctors are posted at CHC Nungba none atte.....

23-Jan-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

Kachai overcomes odds, increases lemon yield

IMPHAL | Jan 22 Despite insufficient rainfall and increase in insect occurrence, the annual yield of the Kachai lemon recorded over 5 metric tonnes this year. This figure was recorded as products sold in the annual lemon festival held every year on Janu.....

23-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Wanton killing decried, many warn 24 hour general strike

KANGPOKPI | Jan 22 Taking strong exception of the prevalence of wanton killings by anti social elements in the state, Kuki Inpi Kangpokpi District including Kuki Students’ Organization Kangpokpi District and Kuki Women Union Kangpokpi District decry such.....

23-Jan-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Latest Comments