Tuesday, 21 February 2017

Editorials 


The Modi Divide

The unseemly scuffle on Sunday in New York's iconic Madison Square Garden, in which the former chief editor of the major TV channel CNN-IBN was heckled by NRI supporters of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, ahead of the latter's public appearance there, tells of several rather portentous pictures of new India which go far beyond just the incivility of the immediate event. It tells for instance of the direction in which the Indian media and how it perceives the ethic of journalism are evolving. This became loudly evident in the manner major media establishments in the country, including most visibly the TV channels, for whatever their reasons, chose to virtually ignore the event. We are talking about here of a man who was once thought to be an important face of Indian journalism. Sardesai was at this venue, famous among many others for having been the arena of some of the best remembered world boxing heavyweight title fights through the 1970s and 80s, including some of the man who floated like a butterfly and stung like a bee and captured the imagination of boxing fans of the time throughout the world, to interview the crowd gathered there and have a sense of the mood there. It is quite an irony that Sardesai was pushed into a sparring match on these same hallowed grounds, though this bout had all the stink of infamy rather than fame. From the few reports available, basically after alerts that Sardesai himselve tweeted, he in his characteristic style, asked very provocative questions about the Prime Minister and of his NRI supporters, when he was confronted by some of Modi's ardent supporters. This is understandable and can happened wherever and whenever overprotective fans feel their icon is being slighted, but what is confounding is, why have the Indian media remained silent on the matter, especially when one of their own, and a very senior and reputed member too, is the man in the spotlight.

Beyond the immediate issue of the media’s response and coverage of the event, the episode has once again reinforced distinctly the larger than life charisma of the controversial Prime Minister, Narendra Modi. No other political leader of Independent India, apart from those who emerged out of the Independence struggle against the British, has arguably achieved such a level of public engagement. Modi is turning out to be one of those public figures who few can remain indifferent to. People either love him passionately or hate him bitterly. This was always so long before he became Prime Minister, but after becoming the Prime Minister, there seems no other way of assessing him or his policies but from the divergent viewpoints of the two extreme poles his entry into National politics has created. Postings on social networking sites such as Facebook will bear evidence anytime, and since on these sites "friends"are generally not restricted to actual friends, (except for puritans who accept only real friends as “friends” and send out “friends” requests to only actual friends) therefore belong to all political and ideological hues, these posting can be treated somewhat as representing a cross section of the society rather than bear likeness to sharing of ideas between an association of like-minded people, as is normally the case in a group of actual friends. No need for elaboration, for all would have noticed that one camp sees him as India’s saviour and another as the harbinger of India’s ultimate disaster.

There is nothing wrong in people holding divergent ideologies, for indeed, this is one of the attributes of a free society. But as another veteran journalist, Vinod Mehta noted, this difference cannot be considered harmless if it begins to accentuate communal hatred, a curse India has been afflicted with in all of its life as a modern sovereign nation. If it does, it can actually spell the ruin of India. To this assertion, probably all in the Northeast will want to caution of the possibility of the polarised political scenario in the country beginning to acquire a racial tint as well. In either of the cases, it may very well be that such a scenario is not the least of what the leadership of the country intends or desires. But between the leaders and followers can often be a wide gulf in understanding as well as approach. The scuffle in Madison Square Garden in New York on Sunday should have provided a glimpse to all of how ugly this gulf can become.

Leader writer: Pradip Phanjoubam

1-Oct-2014 / IFP Editorials / 1 Comments

Comments


JOSHY JOSEPH

1-Oct-2014 | 01:04 PM

THE MOST DEAFENING SILENCE WAS FROM THE MOST VISIBLE AND CELEBRATED ONES.IT'S HEARTENING TO READ AN IFP EDITORIAL ON IT.PEOPLE ARE WATCHING AND HISTORY IN DUE COURSE WILL MARK THE SPAM AS SPAM.AS ANOTHER FILMMAKER PUT IT - THE GREATEST LESSON HISTORY TEACHES US THAT NO ONE LEARNS FROM HISTORY.BUT TOMORROW MAY BE WHEN YOUR TURN COME, YOU MAY OPEN UP OR SHUT UP YOUR ALWAYS BLABBERING MOUTHS. JOSHY JOSEPH, BENCY JOSHY AND JOSE JOSHY



Random Items 

IT dept freezes Rs. 12 crs in poll bound Manipur

IMPHAL | Feb 20 The income tax department has claimed to have detected Rs 12 crores in various raids conducted by surveillance teams of Investigating Wing in connection with the upcoming election. Speaking to reporters at the Hotel Grande, conference ha.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

13 year old raped

IMPHAL | Feb 20 A 13 year old girl was allegedly raped by a 47 year old man at the under construction building site of Horticulture Department, Sanjenthong, Imphal East. The incident took place on17th of this month at around 6 pm. According to the sour.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Top post for Hangkhanlian: Chaoba

CCDPUR | Feb 20 Top BJP leader Th Chaoba today campaigned hard for party candidate V Hangkhanlian of Churachandpur constituency giving a hint that he would be given a top post in the next government. Th Chaoba was speaking at the flag hoisting function o.....

21-Feb-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

Posthumous honour for Kanhailal

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Theatre legend of Manipur, Hesinam Kanhailal, who is also the founder and director of Kalakshetra Manipur, was posthumously honored with the prestigious Ammannur puraskaram instituted by Kerala Sangeetha Nataka Academi, department of cult.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Two days seminar at MU

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Two days seminar on North East India since 1947 under society, polity and economy with reference to the state of Manipur began today at Committee Room, Vice Chancellor’s Office, Manipur University, Canchipur, Imphal. The seminar was orga.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

11 candidates in Chandel and Tengnoupal

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Eleven candidates are in poll fray in 41-Chandel and 42-Tengnoupal ACs with the withdrawal of candidature by an independent candidate namely KB Kothang in Tengnoupal AC on the last day of withdrawal of candidature today. Earlier, seven c.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

International eye care day on March 3

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Since the first International Conference on prevention and Rehabilitation of hearing impairment was held in Beijing, China on March 3rd 2007, the day is observed as ‘International Ear-care Day’ every year across the world. The day is obs.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Shrinking aspirations

It is alarming to note the manner in which aspirations in Manipur by and large have been systematically shrinking in size and scope. Today, it is as if young people see no other handle to success in life than securing a government job – any government job.....

21-Feb-2017 | IFP Editorials | 0 Comments

ZUF threatening Congress

IMPHAL | Feb 20 BJP in nexus with armed group of Zeliangrong United Front (ZUF) are threatening Congress workers in the Khoupum sub division of Noney district, charged Manipur Pradesh Congress Committee (MPCC) spokesperson Khumukcham Joykishan Singh. Jo.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Framework agreement would not affect state: Biren

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Former MLA Nongthombam Biren assured that the framework agreement would not adversely affect the state. Addressing at a flag hoisting ceremony for Bharitya Janata Party (BJP) candidate Yumkham Erabot Singh of Wangkhei assembly constituen.....

21-Feb-2017 | Our Staff Reporter | 0 Comments

Free educational institutions: KNF

KANGPOKPI | Feb 20 The Education department of Kuki National Front (KNF) in its aim to boost education sector in the district today appeals all concerned to make educational institutions of Kangpokpi district a free and peaceful zone. A release stated t.....

21-Feb-2017 | Correspondent | 0 Comments

4 withdraws nomination 

IMPHAL | Feb 20 Four candidates have withdrawn their candidatures on the last date of withdrawal for the first phase of the ensuing 11th state assembly election, to be held on March 8. The candidates are one each from Lilong, Wangjing Tentha, Jiribam a.....

21-Feb-2017 | Press Release | 0 Comments

Latest Comments